Experimental and Computational Evaluation of Nicotinamide Cofactor Biomimetics

Oxidoreductase enzymes are widely used biocatalysts due to their high enantioselectivity and broad substrate compatibility in useful transformations. Many oxidoreductases require nicotinamide cofactors (i.e., NAD(P)H). To replace this costly natural cofactor, synthetic nicotinamide cofactor biomimetics (NCBs) offer different shapes, binding affinities, and reducing potentials that exceed the capabilities of wild-type NAD(P)H. However, the ill-defined structure-activity relationships (SARs) of various NCBs slow rationally guided innovation, such as customized reducing potentials. Here, we dissect two essential elements of NCB design, holding the nicotinamide invariant. First, the linker length between the nicotinamide and an unconjugated aromatic ring uncovered unexpected benefits to redox activity for two or three carbon linkers. Second, substitution on this unconjugated aryl group (Ring 2) might not be expected to affect activity. However, SAR trends demonstrate substantial benefits to reductive potential conferred by electron-donating functionalities on Ring 2. Furthermore, catalysis by two enzymes demonstrates enzyme-dependent tolerance or sensitivity to the NCB structures. Density functional theory (DFT) and computational modeling provide a theoretical framework to understand and build upon these observations. Ring 2 reaches up to the nicotinamide to stabilize its positive charge after oxidation through π-π stacking and charge transfer. Thus, the systematic examination of NCB's stability, electrochemical redox potentials, and kinetics uncovers trends for the improved design of NCBs.