Related Experiment Video
Updated: Sep 18, 2025

Topical Application Bioassay to Quantify Insecticide Toxicity for Mosquitoes and Fruit Flies
Published on: January 19, 2022
Laboratory and semifield data indicate that vector Culicoides spp. in Florida are susceptible to permethrin
Vilma M Cooper1, Eva A Buckner1, Juan M Campos-Krauer2
1Florida Medical Entomology Laboratory, Department of Entomology and Nematology, Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences, University of Florida, Vero Beach, FL, USA.
Abstract:
The genus Culicoides includes numerous species that are biting nuisances and vectors of pathogens affecting humans, livestock, and wildlife. For instance, Culicoides paraensis is the primary vector of Oropouche virus to humans, while other species, such as Culicoides sonorensis, Culicoides insignis, and Culicoides venustus transmit viruses causing hemorrhagic disease in ruminants, particularly bovids and cervids. Current control practices for biting midges rely heavily on chemical insecticides, yet their efficacy and potential for insecticide resistance in biting midges remain poorly documented. We conducted laboratory and semifield experiments to evaluate permethrin susceptibility in wild biting midges collected on 5 Florida deer farms, including known and suspected hemorrhagic diseasevector species, using lab-reared mosquitoes (Aedes aegypti) as a susceptible reference. The Culicoides species tested included: C. insignis (n = 944), C. stellifer (n = 269), C. debilipalpis (n = 68), C. venustus (n = 16), C. edeni (n = 5), C. furens (n = 5). Centers for Disease Control and Prevention bottle bioassays using 10.75 µg permethrin per bottle resulted in 100% mortality within 30 min across all Culicoides spp. Similarly, semifield cage trials with ultra-low volume permethrin-based space sprays applied at maximum label rate caused 100% mortality of all Culicoides spp. and susceptible Ae. aegypti within 1 h after exposure. Our findings confirm the effectiveness of permethrin for controlling biting midges and suggest that significant resistance to permethrin has not developed in the Culicoides populations tested. This study provides a foundation for optimizing vector control strategies against biting midges by demonstrating their susceptibility to permethrin and emphasizing the need for informed, evidence-based practices.
Insights
Permethrin effectively controls biting midges (Culicoides spp.), including disease vectors. Studies show no significant permethrin resistance in tested Florida Culicoides populations, supporting its use in vector control strategies.
Area of Science:
- Veterinary Entomology
- Medical Entomology
- Insecticide Resistance Studies
Background:
- The genus Culicoides comprises biting midges that are significant pests and vectors of pathogens.
- Culicoides paraensis transmits Oropouche virus to humans, while other species transmit viruses causing hemorrhagic disease in livestock.
- Current control methods heavily rely on insecticides, but their efficacy and resistance potential in biting midges are poorly understood.
Purpose of the Study:
- To evaluate the susceptibility of wild biting midges to permethrin.
- To assess potential permethrin resistance in Culicoides populations from Florida deer farms.
- To provide evidence-based data for optimizing biting midge vector control strategies.
Main Methods:
- Laboratory bioassays (CDC bottle bioassays) and semifield cage trials were conducted.
- Wild Culicoides spp. collected from Florida deer farms were tested.
- Permethrin susceptibility was evaluated using standard protocols, with Aedes aegypti as a susceptible reference.
Main Results:
- Permethrin (10.75 µg) resulted in 100% mortality of all tested Culicoides spp. within 30 minutes in laboratory bioassays.
- Semifield trials with permethrin space sprays achieved 100% mortality of Culicoides spp. and Ae. aegypti within 1 hour.
- No significant permethrin resistance was detected in the evaluated Culicoides populations.
Conclusions:
- Permethrin is highly effective for controlling various Culicoides species, including potential disease vectors.
- Current Culicoides populations in the studied Florida areas exhibit susceptibility to permethrin.
- Findings support the continued and informed use of permethrin in integrated biting midge management programs.

