Related Experiment Video
Updated: Sep 14, 2025

A High-Fidelity Porcine Model of Orthotopic Heart Transplantation Following Donation after Circulatory Death
Published on: June 6, 2025
"No Hearts Left Behind": A global proposal to rescue discarded donor hearts
Arezu Aliabadi-Zuckermann1, Andreas Zuckermann1, Mandeep R Mehra2
1Department of Cardiac and Thoracic Aortic Surgery, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Insights
Thousands of viable donor hearts are discarded annually, but transatlantic exchange could save lives. Advanced preservation and shared criteria can enable global organ sharing, reducing waitlist deaths.
Area of Science:
- Cardiology and Transplant Surgery
- Organ Preservation Technology
- Global Health Policy
Background:
- Significant numbers of donor hearts are discarded annually, particularly in the US, while patients face long waitlists.
- Disparities exist in donor acceptance criteria between regions, leading to the rejection of potentially viable organs.
- Current organ preservation technologies allow for extended transport, overcoming previous geographical limitations.
Discussion:
- A transatlantic donor heart exchange program is proposed, leveraging advanced preservation methods like normothermic ex vivo systems.
- This model necessitates addressing ethical, financial, and regulatory challenges, including international oversight and equitable allocation.
- Differences in donor acceptance criteria, especially for older donors, present an opportunity for cross-border transplantation.
Key Insights:
- Advanced preservation techniques enable safe, long-distance transport of donor hearts.
- Harmonizing donor acceptance criteria globally can increase organ utilization.
- A reciprocal allocation framework is crucial for a sustainable international organ sharing system.
Outlook:
- Feasibility trials are proposed to demonstrate the viability of transatlantic heart exchange.
- Global integration of organ sharing, akin to international marrow registries, can reduce waitlist mortality.
- Establishing legal, logistical, and ethical bridges is essential to realize global heart exchange.
Abstract:
Despite technological and logistical progress in heart transplantation, thousands of viable donor hearts are still discarded annually-particularly in the United States-while patients elsewhere continue to die waiting. This viewpoint proposes a global paradigm shift: enabling transatlantic exchange of unused donor hearts through advanced preservation technologies and reciprocal allocation frameworks. Using registry data from Eurotransplant and the United States, we highlight striking disparities in donor acceptance criteria, especially regarding older or donors previously considered less suitable. We argue that many of these organs, declined locally for non-biological reasons, could safely be transplanted in regions where differing practices and technologies allow their use. Advances in preservation-including temperature-controlled static storage, hypothermic oxygenated perfusion, and normothermic ex vivo systems-now permit safe transport over thousands of kilometers, challenging traditional constraints of time and geography. We outline the ethical, financial, and regulatory prerequisites for a transatlantic donor heart exchange system and propose early feasibility trials to initiate proof-of-concept sharing. Such a model would require transparency, international oversight, and an equitable "payback" mechanism to maintain trust and balance. Ultimately, we argue that a globally integrated approach to organ sharing-similar to international marrow registries-could transform access to transplantation, reduce waitlist mortality, and better honor the gift of donation. "No Hearts Left Behind" is more than a slogan: it is an ethical imperative supported by technological feasibility. The time has come to build the bridges-legal, logistical, and moral-that make global heart exchange a reality.

