From Photogrammetry to Virtual Reality: A Framework for Assessing Visual Fidelity in Structural Inspections

Civil structures carry significant service loads over long times but are prone to deterioration due to various natural impacts. Traditionally, these structures are inspected in situ by qualified engineers, a method that is high-cost, risky, time-consuming, and prone to error. Recently, researchers have explored innovative practices by using virtual reality (VR) technologies as inspection platforms. Despite such efforts, a critical question remains: can VR models accurately reflect real-world structural conditions? This study presents a comprehensive framework for assessing the visual fidelity of VR models for structural inspection. To make it viable, we first introduce a novel workflow that integrates UAV-based photogrammetry, computer graphics, and web-based VR editing to establish interactive VR user interfaces. We then propose a visual fidelity assessment methodology that quantitatively evaluates the accuracy of the VR models through image alignment, histogram matching, and pixel-level deviation mapping between rendered images from the VR models and UAV-captured images under matched viewpoints. The proposed frameworks are validated using two case studies: a historic stone arch bridge and a campus steel building. Overall, this study contributes to the growing body of knowledge on VR-based structural inspections, providing a foundation for our peers for their further research in this field.