Research Priorities for Noninvasive Sampling of the Lower Respiratory Tract during Acute Respiratory Failure: An...

Research using lower respiratory tract (LRT) sampling may lead to improved understanding and management of patients with acute respiratory failure (ARF). Research bronchoscopy is a valuable tool for sampling the LRT during ARF. However, bronchoscopy may be limited by challenges with repeated sampling, the inability to sample the most severely ill patients, and increased resource utilization. "Noninvasive" sampling strategies, such as nonbronchoscopic bronchoalveolar lavage, endotracheal aspirate collection, and heat moisture exchange filter fluid collection, may expand the opportunity to collect LRT samples for research. Upper respiratory tract and sputum sampling may enable sampling in nonintubated patients with ARF, for whom there is no direct noninvasive access to the LRT. We convened a workshop with 32 experts from diverse continents, scientific backgrounds, and healthcare professions, all with experience in clinical or research practice during ARF. The Workshop goals were to review existing noninvasive sampling methods, evaluate their respective potential benefits and limitations, and identify future research priorities aimed at improving standardization and integration of these approaches into practice. Findings were generated by review of literature, expert presentations, meeting discussions, and electronic surveys using a modified Delphi approach. Participants agreed that each sampling method provides biologically meaningful data during ARF while also acknowledging that each method has benefits and limitations. Various potential advantages to noninvasive methods include reduced cost, enhanced speed, and ease of adoption compared with standard fiberoptic bronchoscopy. Despite the potential advantages, rigorous head-to-head comparisons between noninvasive methods and/or standard bronchoscopy are limited, which is a priority for future research. Additional research priorities include examination of the feasibility and benefit of serial sampling of the LRT and investigation of how LRT biomarkers are related to lung pathophysiology and patient-centered clinical outcomes during ARF. This Workshop Report provides guidance for investigators to integrate LRT sampling into their research and highlights key priorities, such as rigorous head-to-head comparison of sampling methods for research, to improve the standardization of noninvasive sampling methods and use of LRT sampling in research and clinical practice.