Ethical Issues in Rural Health Research: A Scoping Review

Rural communities experience well-documented systemic disparities in health access and outcomes in comparison to urban populations. However, the ethical dimensions of these disparities have received only limited attention, and ethical issues related to rural health research have received even less. With the COVID-19 pandemic casting new light on these inequities, we conducted a scoping review to determine how much has been written on ethical issues in rural health research and which ethical issues are most prevalent. Four overarching ethical themes emerged through the search: resource inequity, underrepresentation, the benefits of community-based research, and challenges related to participant autonomy. Additionally, the search revealed a dearth of articles on ethical issues in rural health research, particularly in the United States. Thus, we propose four recommendations to revitalize and guide ethics discussions of research in rural communities, including growing the literature on ethical issues in rural U.S. communities, encouraging collaboration between rural health and bioethics researchers, improving recognition of rural heterogeneity, and addressing new issues in light of COVID-19. Acting on these recommendations would expand and support rural research efforts and ultimately help ameliorate rural-urban health inequities.