Selection Signature Analysis of Whole-Genome Sequences to Identify Genome Differences Between Selected and Unselected...

A unique line of Holstein cattle has been maintained without selection in Minnesota since 1964. After many generations, unselected cattle produce less milk, but have better reproductive performance and health traits when compared with contemporary cows. Comparisons between this line of unselected Holstein and those under selection provide useful insights that connect selection and complex traits in cattle. Utilizing these unique resources and sequence data, we sought to identify genome changes due to selection. We sequenced 30 unselected and 54 selected Holstein cattle and compared their sequence variants to identify selection signatures. After many years, the two populations showed completely different patterns in their genome-level population structures and linkage disequilibrium. By integrating signals from five different detection methods, we detected consensus selection signatures from at least four methods covering 14,533 SNPs and 155 protein-coding genes. An integrated analysis of selection signatures with gene annotation, pathways, and the cattle QTL database demonstrated that the genomic regions under selection are related to milk productivity, health, and reproductive efficiency. The polygenic nature of these complex traits is evident from hundreds of selection signatures and candidate genes, suggesting that long-term artificial selection has acted on the whole genome rather than a few major genes. In summary, our study identified candidate selection signatures underlying phenotypic differences between unselected and selected Holstein cows and revealed insights into the genetic basis of complex traits in cattle.