The Role of Phoneme Discrimination in the Variability of Speech and Language Outcomes Among Children with Hearing...

This research compares speech discrimination abilities between 17 children who are hard-of-hearing (CHH) and 13 children with normal hearing (CNH), aged 9 to 36 months, using either a conditioned head turn (CHT) or condition play paradigm, for two phoneme pairs /ba-da/ and /sa-ʃa/. As CHH were tested in the aided and unaided conditions, CNH were also tested on each phoneme contrast twice to control for learning effects. When speech discrimination abilities were compared between CHH, with hearing aids (HAs), and CNH, there were no statistical differences observed in performance on stop consonant discrimination, but a significant statistical difference was observed for fricative discrimination performance. Among CHH, significant benefits were observed for /ba-da/ speech discrimination while wearing HAs, compared to the no HA condition. All CHH were early-identified, early amplified, and were enrolled in parent-centered early intervention services. Under these conditions, CHH demonstrated the ability to discriminate speech comparable to CNH. Additionally, repeated testing within 1-month did not result in a change in speech discrimination scores, indicating good test-retest reliability of speech discrimination scores. Finally, this research explored the question of infant/toddler listening fatigue in the behavioral speech discrimination task. The CHT paradigm included returning to a contrast (i.e., /a-i/) previously shown to be easier for both CHH and CNH to discriminate to examine if failure to discriminate /ba-da/ or /sa-ʃa/ was due to listening fatigue or off-task behavior.