Preliminary perspectives on gene therapy in fragile X syndrome: a caregiver view

There have been increasing numbers of clinical trials of medications for fragile X syndrome (FXS) in recent years, many targeted at proposed underlying cellular or circuit based mechanisms. As yet none of these have led to widespread changes in clinical practice. Genetic therapies represent a different therapeutic approach, which aim to address the genetic mechanisms by which FXS arises. Although not yet moving into human studies in FXS, this is an area of increasing research importance in neurodevelopmental conditions more broadly. It is important that families affected by FXS get the chance to give their views about future genetic therapies, given the potential controversies around genetic therapies.

We developed a questionnaire to capture caregiver views around gene therapy in FXS. The questionnaire was developed alongside a group of parents / caregivers of a child with FXS to ensure the language used was appropriate and that it would allow a variety of views to be captured. The questionnaire contained questions around current knowledge of gene therapy, what families think of gene therapy and their views on gene therapy trials taking place. Responses were analysed by thematic analysis carried out by two of the authors with data from the questionnaires being grouped into themes and subthemes.

The questionnaire was completed by 195 individuals who are parents of, or who care for, someone with FXS. Respondents were primarily from the UK (60.5%) and the Americas (22.1%). The majority of dependants were male (86%). Responses showed a strong interest from the Fragile X community in gene therapy trials taking place, with themes emerging around quality of life, outcomes and feelings. Hope for positive change was balanced against caution about unintended consequences, the newness of the treatment and tolerability.

Overall, caregivers felt hopeful, excited and interested in the prospect of gene therapy potentially providing a new treatment option, but there was some trepidation about the potential effects. Taking caregiver views into account will help inform decisions around the development and testing of any future genetic interventions.