Post-concussion clinical findings of oculomotor function in paediatric patients with persisting symptoms compared to

Carissa H Wu1, Sophia Marusic1, Jennifer X Haensel2

  • 1Boston Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.

Insights

Paediatric concussion patients often have vergence and accommodation deficits. Near point of convergence (NPC) and accommodative amplitude (AA) effectively screen for these persistent oculomotor issues in children.

Area of Science:

  • Pediatric Neurology and Neuro-ophthalmology
  • Oculomotor function screening in sports-related concussion
  • Clinical assessment of persistent concussion symptoms

Background:

Prior research has shown that the intricate neurological coordination required for binocular vision and focus is frequently compromised following mild traumatic brain injuries in developing youth. Pediatric patients often experience a complex constellation of symptoms that persist long after the initial biomechanical insult to the cranium has occurred. Although many clinical protocols focus on cognitive and vestibular recovery, the specific degradation of the oculomotor system in children with chronic symptoms remains an area of active investigation. It was already known that disruptions in the autonomic and somatic control of the extraocular muscles can lead to significant functional impairments in academic and social environments. However, the precise prevalence of vergence and accommodative insufficiency in this specific demographic has not been definitively quantified using standardized prospective methodologies. The recruitment process involved specialized concussion clinics and referrals to vision providers to ensure a representative sample of the symptomatic population. This absence of evidence motivated the current multi-site investigation into the visual performance profiles of symptomatic children compared to their healthy counterparts.

Purpose Of The Study:

This investigation characterizes the specific frequency and severity of oculomotor deficits in pediatric patients who continue to report symptoms months after a diagnosed concussion. The research team sought to delineate the unique visual profile of these individuals by comparing their performance on standardized tests of vergence and accommodation against a control group of healthy peers. This research evaluates whether specific metrics like Near Point of Convergence (NPC) can reliably distinguish between post-concussive pathology and normal physiological variation in children aged 8 to 18. Researchers also examined Accommodative Amplitude (AA) to determine its effectiveness as a diagnostic marker for lingering visual impairments. The project also addresses the need for objective diagnostic criteria that can support clinical decision-making in the management of persistent concussion symptoms. These efforts provide a foundation for developing targeted therapeutic interventions that address the underlying visual dysfunctions hindering pediatric recovery.

Main Methods:

Investigators executed a prospective multi-center study involving seventy-one participants recruited from concussion clinics, eye centers, and local communities across three distinct regions in the United States. The experimental group comprised thirty-four pediatric subjects with a mean age of 14.3 years who met the diagnostic criteria for persistent concussion symptoms at a median of 107 days post-injury. Medical professionals performed a comprehensive battery of visual assessments, including precise measurements of ocular alignment, Near Point of Convergence (NPC), and Accommodative Amplitude (AA) using standardized clinical tools. To ensure statistical rigor, the team used Welch's t-test for continuous variables and Fisher's exact test with Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons. The research group performed logistic regression modeling and calculated the Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve (AUC) to determine the predictive power of specific oculomotor tests. These analytical methods allowed the researchers to determine the Odds Ratio (OR) for each metric, providing a quantitative measure of their predictive power in identifying concussed individuals.

Main Results:

Concussed participants showed a remarkably high frequency of visual dysfunction, with 62% exhibiting vergence deficits and 76% showing accommodative impairments, compared to a mere 3% in the healthy control group. The symptomatic cohort performed significantly worse on nearly every measured parameter, including Near Point of Convergence (NPC) and Accommodative Amplitude (AA), with p-values consistently falling below the 0.05 threshold. Statistical analysis identified Near Point of Convergence (NPC) as a powerful predictor of concussion status, yielding an Odds Ratio (OR) of 2.16 and an impressive mean Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.88. Similarly, Accommodative Amplitude (AA) showed high diagnostic value, producing an Odds Ratio of 0.46 and an identical mean AUC of 0.88, indicating strong diagnostic sensitivity and specificity. While most tests showed clear divergence between the groups, ocular alignment and monocular accommodative facility did not reveal statistically significant differences between the concussed and control participants. These data points collectively illustrate a profound and persistent impact of head injury on the oculomotor systems of children and adolescents well into the chronic recovery phase.

Conclusions:

The findings suggest that pediatric patients with lingering post-concussive issues possess a distinct oculomotor profile characterized by substantial vergence and accommodative failures. Clinicians should prioritize the assessment of Near Point of Convergence (NPC) and Accommodative Amplitude (AA) as primary screening tools during follow-up evaluations for head injuries. These objective visual metrics provide a reliable method for identifying physiological impairments that may otherwise be overlooked in standard neurological exams. Future research must determine if these same oculomotor markers are present during the acute phase of injury or if they evolve over time. Implementing these screening protocols in eye clinics and concussion centers could facilitate earlier intervention and targeted vision therapy for affected children. Ultimately, this research provides a foundational framework for improving the diagnostic accuracy and multidisciplinary management of pediatric concussion survivors.

Abstract

Frequently Asked Questions