Comparative Osseointegration in Different Parts of Bone: A Systematic Review of in vivo Experiments

Osseointegration is critical for the long-term success of endosteal implants, as it is influenced by factors such as implant design, material selection, and site of implantation. Considering the structural and vascular properties of trabecular bone, it is reasonable to hypothesize that osseointegration could be enhanced in this region. However, emerging evidence indicates that cortical bone frequently offers a more favorable environment for osseointegration. The objective was to conduct a systematic review of preclinical translational studies comparing osseointegration outcomes around implants placed in cortical and trabecular bone. Preclinical studies comparing bone-to-implant contact (BIC) and bone area fraction occupied (BAFO) between cortical and trabecular regions in animals with solid endosteal implants were retrieved from the PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane databases. We included randomized and nonrandomized preclinical translational trials published in English between 2014 and 2024 that reported at least one outcome of interest. Exclusion criteria comprised in vitro or ex vivo experiments, research involving human subjects, studies using powder, liquid, or plasma implants, abstracts, technical descriptions, and narrative or systematic reviews. The systematic review comprised 15 studies, which included a total of 298 animals and 877 implants. The mean follow-up period ranged between 4 and 17 weeks. In 13 studies, the cortical bone region demonstrated higher BIC values, with differences in BIC between cortical and trabecular bone ranging from 5.55% to 49.55% during the first 4 weeks, 1.80% to 51.30% between 4 and 8 weeks, and 9.65% to 35.41% following the 8-week healing period. Regarding BAFO values, data were reported in three studies, all of which indicated elevated values in cortical bone. The mean difference in the first 4 weeks ranged from 15.83% to 29.92%, and from 26.33% to 60.11% after 4 weeks of healing. These findings suggest that cortical regions exhibit enhanced short- and long-term osseointegration outcomes compared to trabecular bone regions.Impact StatementThe specific site of implantation significantly influences the degree and rate of osseointegration. Trabecular bone, characterized by its high porosity and larger surface area relative to volume, facilitates the diffusion of nutrients and oxygen from the surrounding marrow and blood vessels. Nevertheless, emerging evidence indicates that cortical bone, due to its greater density and superior mechanical properties, often provides a more stable environment for osseointegration compared to trabecular bone. This systematic review of preclinical studies represents the first comprehensive effort to evaluate and compare osseointegration in cortical versus trabecular bone.