Meiotic Recombination May Be Initiated by Copy Choice During DNA Synthesis Rather than Break/Join Mechanism

Our understanding of the molecular mechanisms by which DNA meiotic recombination occurs has significantly increased in the past decades. A more representative molecular model has also undergone repeated revisions and upgrades with the continuous expansion of experimental data. Considering several apparent issues in the field, we intend to make necessary upgrades to previous models and reanalyze those data, exploring structural details and molecular mechanisms of DNA meiotic recombination. Eligible studies were identified from PubMed/Medline (up to June 2024). Key related publications and experimental data were retrieved from eligible studies, displaying five major issues. Meanwhile, the biophysical modeling method was used to establish an enlacement model. Then, the model was used to wholly reanalyze the collected data. An updated molecular model was supplemented. In the current model, a copy choice mechanism can initiate DNA meiotic recombination. The copy choice is based on a branched structure of DNA, which results from relative motion between homologous single strands. The reanalysis of previous experimental data based on this model can lead to new interpretations that can better address the discrepancies between previous experimental observations and theoretical models, including (1) the intertwinement model having embodied the particular characteristics of the SDSA model; (2) hDNA arising from JM resolution rather than being followed by a JM; (3) strand specificity of hDNA mismatch repair seeming to be an illusion and copy choice more likely to be the actual state; (4) parity in resolution patterns of a dHJ leading to parity of gene conversion; (5) the cooperation of multiple HJs readily generating a high correlation between gene conversion and crossover; and (6) transpositional recombination and site-specific recombination seeming to have a common pathway to meiotic recombination. The results indicate that both revisions and reanalysis are necessary. The novel interpretations would be critical to the understanding of the mechanisms of DNA recombination as well as its role in DNA repair. Additionally, the work could have implications for how the field views the importance of factors such as Spo11 or the mechanisms that drive meiotic pairing.