Thermodynamic control of gene regulation

G-quadruplexes and i-motifs are non-canonical secondary structures of DNA that act as conformational switches in controlling genomic events. Within the genome, G- and C-rich sequences with the potential to fold into G-quadruplexes and i-motifs are overrepresented in important regulatory domains, including, but not limited to, the promoter regions of oncogenes. We previously have shown that some promoter sequences can adopt coexisting duplex, G-quadruplex, i-motif, and coiled conformations; moreover, their distribution can be modelled as a dynamic equilibrium in which the fractional population of each conformation is determined by the sequence and local conditions. On that basis, we proposed a hypothesis in which the level of expression of a gene with G- and C-rich sequences in the promoter is regulated thermodynamically by fine-tuning the duplex-to-G-quadruplex ratio, with the G-quadruplex modulating RNA polymerase activity. Any deviation from the evolutionarily tuned, gene-specific distribution of conformers, such as might result from mutations in the promoter or a change in cellular conditions, may lead to under- or overexpression of the gene and pathological consequences. We now expand on this hypothesis in the context of supporting evidence from molecular and cellular studies and from biophysico-chemical investigations of oligomeric DNA. Thermodynamic control of transcription implies that G-quadruplex and i-motif structures in the genome form as thermodynamically stable conformers in competition with the duplex conformation. That is in addition to their recognized formation as kinetically trapped, metastable states within domains of single-stranded DNA, such as a transcription bubble or R-loop, that are opened in a prior cellular event.