Modeling active nematics via the nematic locking principle

Active nematic systems consist of rod-like internally driven subunits that interact with one another to form large-scale coherent flows. They are important examples of far-from-equilibrium fluids, which exhibit a wealth of nonlinear behavior. This includes active turbulence, in which topological defects in the nematic order braid around one another in a chaotic fashion. One of the most studied examples of active nematics consists of a dense two-dimensional layer of microtubules, crosslinked by kinesin molecular motors that inject extensile deformations into the fluid. Though numerous theoretical studies have modeled microtubule-based active nematics, no consensus has emerged on how to fully and quantitatively capture the features of the experimental system. To better understand the theoretical foundations for modeling this system, we propose a fundamental principle we call the nematic locking principle-individual microtubules cannot rotate without all neighboring microtubules also rotating. Physically, this is justified by the high density of the microtubules, their elongated nature, and their corresponding steric interactions. We assert that the nematic locking principle holds throughout the majority of the material, but breaks down in the neighborhood of topological defects and other regions of low density. We derive the most general nematic transport equation consistent with this principle and also derive the most general term that violates it, introducing fracturing into the material. We then examine the standard Beris-Edwards approach, commonly used to model this system, and show that it violates the nematic locking principle throughout the majority of the material due to fracturing. We then propose a modification to the Beris-Edwards model that enforces nematic locking nearly everywhere. This modification shuts off fracturing except in regions where the order parameter (a proxy for density) is reduced. In these regions fracturing is turned on. The resulting simulations in turn show strong nematic locking throughout the bulk of the material, with narrow bands of fracturing, consistent with experimental observation. One additional advantage of enforcing nematic locking is that nontrivial stationary state solutions, common in Beris-Edwards simulations but not seen in experiments, are eliminated.