Comparison of Clinical Development of Digital Therapeutics among Japan, the Unites States, and Germany

Digital therapeutics (DTx) have demonstrated promising potential as a novel therapeutic approach, with their clinical development gaining momentum. Comparison of DTx development between Japan, a relative newcomer, and Germany and the U.S., known for favorable circumstances, is a topic of interest. DTx developed in Japan as of November 2023 were identified on the Pharmaceuticals and Medical Devices Agency (PMDA) website and in the literature. Similar DTx available in the U.S. and Germany were identified in the databases maintained by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (USFDA) and Federal Institute for Drugs and Medical Devices (BfArM). Data on their clinical trials and regulatory status were obtained from these databases and their respective national clinical trial registries. The data obtained were compared and analyzed. By November 2023, Japan had developed DTx, encompassing 11 therapeutic areas. Seven DTx had reached or completed the confirmatory study stage, whereas five DTx were in the exploratory phase. Twenty DTx in the therapeutic areas were selected from the U.S. and Germany. A total of 27 DTx were reviewed regarding the designs of confirmatory studies and regulatory actions taken. Trial designs demonstrated more similarities than differences across the countries and therapeutic areas. Placebo trial design-associated difficulties were conspicuous. Although regulatory actions to place DTx in the market differed across countries, they effectively ensured the efficacy and safety of DTx that were suitable for marketing considering the most current science. The regulatory measures in the three countries seem to have positively impacted DTx development.