From visualization to education: the role of 3D-Printed and virtual kidney models in training for renal cancer...

This systematic review on novel 3D technologies aims to discuss the current evidence on the usefulness of 3D printing, virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) simulators in the education and training of young urologists for kidney cancer surgery, highlighting the modalities employed, their educational impact, and areas for future development. We performed a comprehensive literature search limited to the last 10 years across PubMed and Embase libraries, identifying studies evaluating the use of 3D technologies as educational tools in urologist training for kidney cancer surgery. The review followed PRISMA guidelines, and two reviewers independently screened eligible studies. We extracted data on study designs and on urologists' education outcomes, through different subcategories. Seventeen studies were included, mostly small-scale validation or descriptive investigations. Twelve investigated 3D-printed models and five VR/AR platforms. Simulations focused on laparoscopic and robot-assisted partial nephrectomy, often using patient-specific models for rehearsal and skill development. Training outcomes included improved spatial anatomy understanding, increased technical performance, greater procedural confidence, and enhanced familiarity with complex surgical steps. However, considerable heterogeneity in methodology and limited sample sizes across studies underscore the need for standardized evaluation of these educational tools. 3D technologies, including 3D-printed models and VR/AR platforms, show promise in enhancing surgical training for renal cancer by improving anatomical understanding and procedural skills. These technologies demonstrate good precision and can help assess trainee surgical skill. However, evidence remains limited, and further research is needed to validate their effectiveness, cost-efficiency, and integration into standardized urological training curricula.