Purchasing Versus Providing Care at the VHA: Quality Differences in Follow-Up After Psychiatric Hospitalization

The Veterans Health Administration (VHA) greatly expanded the proportion of health care services it purchases from community providers over the last decade, which could impact the quality of care and create care fragmentation. Continuity of care between inpatient and outpatient care delivery systems is critical for high-quality mental health care.

To compare rates of outpatient follow-up visits between VHA-purchased and VHA-delivered psychiatric hospitalizations, overall and by VHA facility.

Using VHA electronic medical records and community care claims data, we compared 7-day and 30-day outpatient follow-up rates across VHA-purchased and VHA-delivered settings. We estimated follow-up rates and comparisons overall as well as separately for 4 diagnosis groups and separately across VHA facilities.

Our sample included 64,784 hospitalizations; more than 30% were VHA-purchased as opposed to VHA-delivered. Compared with VHA-delivered hospitalizations, follow-up rates were 30.1 (95% CI: 27.8-32.5) percentage points lower at 7 days and 22.5 (95% CI: 20.8-24.1) percentage points lower at 30 days for VHA-purchased hospitalizations. Lower follow-up rates occurred for neurocognitive disorder discharges for both VHA-purchased and delivered care. Follow-up rates at 30 days were significantly lower for VHA-purchased hospitalizations at 121 out of 128 facilities and significantly higher at no facility.

VHA enrollees seeking mental health care and VHA program managers could benefit from data on psychiatric care quality differences between community providers and VHA providers. From a system perspective, VHA-purchased care quality reports and value-based purchasing contracts could include outpatient follow-up quality measures to incentivize higher quality care.