Proteolytic Activities and Immunological Effects of Light Chains of Botulinum Neurotoxin A1, A2 and A3 Subtypes

Botulinum neurotoxin serotype A (BoNT/A) is the most potent known neurotoxin. While its light chain (LC) catalytic domain is a prime target for next-generation vaccines and therapeutics, the functional differences among BoNT/A subtype LCs (A1, A2, A3) remain to be definitively characterized, despite notable sequence variation. This work aimed to systematically compare the proteolytic activity and immunoprotective efficacy of recombinant BoNT/A1-LC, A2-LC, and A3-LC. Recombinant A1-LC-His, A2-LC-His, A3-LC-His, and A3-LC-Twin-Strep proteins were expressed in Escherichia coli (E. coli) and purified with affinity chromatography. Their proteolytic activity was assessed via in vitro SNAP-25 cleavage assays. The protective potency of these antigens was evaluated in a mouse model. In vitro cleavage assays revealed a substrate cleavage efficiency order of A2-LC > A1-LC > A3-LC. In vivo, both A1-LC and A2-LC immunization conferred robust, broad protection against high-dose challenges with all three toxin subtypes. In stark contrast, A3-LC provided only minimal protection against its homologous toxin and none against heterologous subtypes. Crucially, the functional deficit of A3-LC was confirmed to be an intrinsic property, as the A3-LC-TS variant, designed to exclude tag-specific interference, exhibited comparable low efficacy. According to structural research, A3-LC's compromised function may be caused by a four-amino-acid loss. The inferior performance of A3-LC is inherent to its primary structure. This work identified A1-LC or A2-LC as the potential proteolytic activity molecule and vaccine antigen by demonstrating functional differences among BoNT/A subtype LCs. These findings provide crucial insights for developing subtype-specific countermeasures against botulism.