The clinical utility of genome sequencing is multi-dimensional: experience from the Hong Kong Genome Project

Assessing clinical utility of genome sequencing (GS) is essential for healthcare decisions. This study quantified the multidimensional utility of GS using the validated Clinician-reported Genetic testing Utility InDEx (C-GUIDE) within a diverse rare disease cohort at the Hong Kong Genome Project.

Adult and paediatric patients suspected of genetic disorders were recruited from the Hong Kong Children's Hospital. Clinical geneticists evaluated GS utility based on 17 items. Total C-GUIDE utility scores and global item scores were calculated, with individual item scores ranging from -2 to 2.

Between March and July 2024, three clinical geneticists completed 247 C-GUIDE ratings for 245 probands, with 25% receiving positive, 7% inconclusive, and 69% negative GS results. Total C-GUIDE scores ranges from -1 to 30, with a mean of 6.1 (SD = 10.0). Multivariate regression analysis indicates that positive GS findings are associated with a 16.9-point increase in C-GUIDE scores compared to inconclusive or negative results (p < 0.001). Notably, the highest mean scores are observed in psychosocial benefits for patients and families, regardless of GS results. The mean global item score, representing overall assessment of clinical utility, is 0.53 (SD = 0.06). Baseline patient characteristics are not independently associated with C-GUIDE scores.

This study represents the first and largest of its kind in the Asia Pacific region, highlighting the multidimensional benefits of GS and the importance of nationwide Genome Projects. By highlighting that clinical utility is primarily influenced by test results rather than patient characteristics, this study underscores the importance of equitable GS implementation across populations.