Retrospective Analysis of the Heifetz and Winograd Methods in the Surgical Treatment of Ingrown Toenails

Background: We sought to compare the results of the Heifetz and Winograd methods, used in the surgical treatment of ingrown toenails, and their efficacy in different age groups. Methods: A total of 160 toes of 143 patients surgically treated with the diagnosis of toes growing into the skin between 1 June 2012, and 31 July 2019 were evaluated retrospectively. The age, sex, involved foot, involved toe, and relevant Heifetz stages of the patients were assessed. The patients underwent either the Winograd or Heifetz surgical treatment method. The groups were further divided by age (<18 years and ≥18 years) and were re-evaluated in terms of recurrence. Results: No statistically significant difference was detected between the groups in terms of age, sex, side, early infection, and recurrence rates. However, when the groups were divided according to age, a significantly lower recurrence rate was found in patients younger than 18 years who underwent the Heifetz method compared with patients 18 years and older who underwent the Winograd method. Conclusions: Aligned with the literature, these two surgical methods may be regarded as considerably successful, easily applied, and safe, with fewer complications in ingrown toenail cases. Although it is appropriate to select a surgical treatment method depending on the experience of the surgeon, we believe that the Heifetz method should be given priority due to better outcomes in terms of recurrence in patients younger than 18 years.