Exploring Communication Dynamics and Perceptions in Radiology Readouts: A Comparative Analysis of Peer and Mentored...

Background: Radiology readouts, which involve student-teacher (mentored) and student-student (peer) interactions, are a cornerstone of medical education; however, communication dynamics in these settings, and students' perceptions of them, are underexplored. This qualitative study examined medical students' perceptions of peer and mentored learning during radiology readouts and analyzed associated verbal communication patterns. Methods: This qualitative observational study was conducted at Maastricht University in the Netherlands between April and May 2023. We conducted the study in three stages: (1) observation of student-student interactions, (2) observation of student-teacher interactions, and (3) semi-structured interviews with students about their perceptions of these interactions. We categorized verbal communication data using an adapted Verbal Response Modes (VRM) taxonomy, grouping intents into cognitive structuring, instructing, and questioning. We analyzed the interview data thematically. Results: Verbal communication analysis revealed that cognitive structuring during student-student interactions primarily involved disclosure and confirmation, while student-teacher interactions also included interpretation. Questioning was consistent across both interaction types, but instructing, such as advisement, was more prevalent in student-teacher interactions. We identified two key themes in the interview data. Theme 1: Peer interactions fostered uncertainty, while teacher interactions provided certainty through accurate information. Theme 2: Peer interactions facilitated verbalization of thoughts, whereas teacher interactions enhanced thought processes through meaningful prompts and insights. Conclusion: These findings indicate that student-teacher interactions are more responsive (interpretation) and directive (advisement), promoting certainty and deeper discussion, whereas student-student interactions, though more egocentric (disclosure), support thorough articulation despite perceived uncertainty. This study informs the design of radiology education by highlighting the complementary roles of peer and teacher interactions in fostering diagnostic reasoning and managing uncertainty.