Non-reciprocal coevolution in a fungus-gardening ant

Symbioses are often characterized by nonrandom associations between hosts and symbionts. Hosts may obtain symbionts horizontally from the environment or vertically from a parent or sometimes use both methods. Macroevolutionary examinations of fungus-gardening ants and their fungi have shown either a 1:1 coevolution model or a 'diffuse' model between ant host and fungal symbionts. However, some of these conclusions may have been based on using relatively conservative molecular markers, which could obscure cryptic variation. The use of whole genome approaches potentially offer more power in elucidating coevolutionary history. In this study, we examined patterns of coevolution in a single species (Trachymyrmex septentrionalis) using genomic and experimental approaches. We tested whether ant-fungal specificity patterns reflected either 1:1 or diffuse models of coevolution. While we report significant co-phylogenetic signal among intraspecific ant host and fungal symbiont lineages, we found evidence of 1:1 coevolution in some lineages and diffuse in others. These conclusions were supported by the results of experiments where newly mated T. septentrionalis queens were forced to grow novel fungi that suggested that not all fungi are equivalent symbionts and would require specialized hosts. Thus, within a single ant species, there is a mixed support for both models.