Unravelling the Intrinsic Reactivity and Colloidal Instability in Tin-Based Halide Perovskite Precursor Solutions

Narrow-bandgap tin and mixed tin-lead halide perovskites are attracting growing interest for optoelectronic applications, yet the difficult-to-control crystallization process has hindered their development. Although additive engineering has effectively improved film formation, the fundamental origins of their distinct crystallization behavior remain less explored. Here, through direct comparison with Pb counterparts, we investigate the pre-crystallization stages of Sn-based perovskite precursor solutions through complementary structural characterizations. We show that Sn precursors are intrinsically more reactive and sensitive to their chemical environment, exhibiting poorer colloidal stability compared to Pb and a strong inherent tendency to agglomerate. These findings explain their narrower processing window, where small variations in solution chemistry strongly affect nucleation and crystallization dynamics. To fabricate high-quality tin-based perovskite through solution methods, we highlight the importance of controlling the often-overlooked pre-crystallization stages, though, for example, rational solvent and additive designs. Overall, we provide fundamental insights into precursor solution chemistry and establish pre-crystallization engineering as a key strategy for overcoming long-standing limitations in thin-film fabrication, particularly in light of the field's rapid progression toward large-scale, sustainable, and solvent-conscious manufacturing.