Stability and Reactivity of Cyclopentane Nucleoside Analogs in 98% w/w Sulfuric Acid

We synthesized seven carbocyclic nucleoside analogs featuring a cyclopentane ring in place of the (deoxy)ribose sugar, which serves as a linker in DNA/RNA nucleosides. We assessed the stability of cyclopentane nucleosides in 98% w/w sulfuric acid at room temperature via ¹H and ¹³C NMR spectroscopy. We observe that adenine (A1, A4), guanine (G1) and thymine (T1) cyclopentane nucleoside analogs remain stable for at least two weeks at room temperature, with only minor (~4%) degradation in A1. In contrast, the cytosine analog (C1) rapidly degrades to release a soluble cytosine. Methyl-substituted adenine analogs mimicking polymer backbone attachments at positions prone to tertiary carbocation formation (A2, A3) prove unstable and release soluble adenine. Only the 3,3-dimethylcyclopentyl adenine analog (A4) exhibits sufficient stability. Our findings reveal that cyclopentane serves as a viable stable linker in concentrated sulfuric acid for select nucleic acid bases, provided that the backbone connections avoid tertiary carbons susceptible to carbocation-mediated cleavage. We thus identify one potential key structural feature for engineering examples of genetic-like polymers that could potentially persist in Venus's concentrated sulfuric acid cloud environment.