Comparative Performance of SARC-F, SARC-CalF, SARC-F + EBM, and Ishii Score for Detecting Sarcopenia in Hospitalised...

Background/Objectives: Sarcopenia is a progressive decline in skeletal muscle strength and mass, leading to decreased functionality, metabolic disorders, morbidity, and mortality. There are a number of sarcopenia screening tools, such as the SARC-F questionnaire (that includes noting strength, assistance with walking, ability to raise from the chair, climb stairs, and falls), with its augmented forms that have added calf circumference (SARC-CalF), BMI and age (SARC-F + EBM), and the Ishii score, which show variable performance across populations. However, these were developed and validated mostly in Asian cohorts. To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of these tools for the European Working Group on Sarcopenia in Older People (EWGSOP2), as well as define sarcopenia in hospitalized East European older adults, with sex and obesity stratification. Methods: Sarcopenia was diagnosed using the EWGSOP2. ROC analyses with DeLong tests assessed SARC-F, SARC-CalF, SARC-F + EBM, and the Ishii score in 278 Romanian inpatients (probable sarcopenia n = 201/278, 72.3%; confirmed n = 77/278, 27.7%). Results: Probable sarcopenia was noted as good-excellent discrimination against across all tools (AUCs 0.764-0.812); confirmed sarcopenia was noted as SARC-CalF superior (AUC = 0.743), followed by SARC-F + EBM (0.697), the Ishii score as moderate (0.667), and SARC-F was limited (0.591; p < 0.001 vs. augmented). SARC-CalF optimal cut-offs varied significantly: 4-6 (probable) vs. ≥11 (confirmed). Sex-stratified outcomes had excellent probable detection in both sexes, and this was confirmed to be superior in men. The Ishii score thresholds were 152/244 vs. Asian ≥ 105/120. Obesity required higher cut-offs with high NPVs (77-100%), confirming rule-out utility and SARC-F + EBM performing the best, both in the obesity and sarcopenic obesity subgroups (AUCs 0.742, 0.964). Conclusions: Augmented SARC-F scores outperformed the original SARC-F for confirmed sarcopenia in multimorbid Europeans, with SARC-F CalF having the best performance overall. Population-specific (sex/obesity) data-driven thresholds are essential, especially for the Ishii score, as this first Romanian validation reveals limitations of Asian norms in European cohorts, thus advocating for European recalibration.