When Does Directional Reflectance Matter? Evaluating BRDF Effects in Plant Canopy Light Simulations

Virtual plant models combined with ray-tracing simulations are an established tool for evaluating plant-light interactions. Current approaches often simplify leaf surface properties by assuming diffuse reflectance behavior, despite experimental evidence that leaf reflectance is direction-dependent across much of the visible spectrum. This study investigates whether incorporating measured, spectrally resolved and direction-dependent (BRDF) reflectance properties into these models affects simulation outcomes. Using virtual 3D cucumber (Cucumis sativus) plant models with PhongShader-based optical leaf characteristics for BRDF consideration, light absorption and local photon flux densities were simulated under a wide range of lighting conditions, including diffuse and directed sunlight scenarios. While total light absorption at the leaf level is only marginally affected (mean absolute percentage error, MAPE < 2%), spectral distortions in leaf surroundings, especially under direct light, exceeded 8% in the blue wavelength range. Beyond their relevance for estimating photosynthetic rates, such distortions directly affect the spectral composition within the canopy, which is particularly critical in greenhouse applications where optical sensors are used to monitor spectral ratios and, therefore, require the accurate prior simulation of canopy light conditions. This is particularly relevant for setups with directional artificial lighting. The findings suggest that BRDF modeling is not critical for calculating photosynthetic rates under most conditions, but is required in spectral analyses or for optimizing artificial lighting designs.