"Maisonneuve type" fracture patients return to activity quicker than patients with other PER III/IV fractures

To compare clinical characteristics and outcomes of Maisonneuve fractures, as defined as syndesmotic disruption with or without proximal fibula fracture, to other pronation-external rotation (PER) stage III/IV fractures.

A retrospective review of an IRB-approved database of ankle fractures from a single orthopedic department identified patients with surgically treated PER stage III/IV fractures, including those meeting radiographic criteria for Maisonneuve fracture. Data collected included patient demographics, injury mechanism, surgical details, and Lauge-Hansen classification. Maisonneuve fractures were compared to other PER III/IV fractures requiring fibular fixation with syndesmotic stabilization. Outcomes included total complications, fracture-related infection, hardware removal, and nonunion. Patients were seen for standard follow up for 12 months post-operatively with clinical healing defined as non-tenderness about the ankle. Statistical analyses included Chi square analysis, ANOVA, and multivariable regression analysis.

64 patients with operatively repaired Maisonneuve fractures were identified (mean follow-up of 10 months). These patients were more often male compared to other PER III/IV fractures (p < 0.05). Maisonneuve fractures were associated with a faster time to clinical healing and return to full activity, confirmed on multivariable regression analysis (p < 0.05). No significant differences in complications rates or radiographic parameters at six months or later were observed, as all values remained within accepted clinical ranges.

Maisonneuve fracture patients experience a more rapid clinical recovery based upon painless ankle motion as well as a return to full activity faster than patients with other types of PER III/IV injuries, with comparable complication rates and radiographic outcomes.