Competition between protein-RNA clustering and phase separation drives re-entrant phase behavior of hnRNPA1

Phase separation of RNA-binding proteins plays crucial roles in the cell and is modulated by RNA, including promotion and suppression at low and high RNA concentrations, respectively. In complex coacervates, suppression of phase separation is rationalized by charge inversion when increasing the concentration of one component. Here, we show that suppression of biomolecular condensates of the RNA-binding protein hnRNPA1 at high RNA concentration is driven by a different mechanism, namely the competition with formation of nano-sized protein-RNA clusters in the dilute phase. We show that the competition is modulated not only by RNA concentration, but also by the type of RNA, with specific RNA being more effective in promoting cluster formation than unspecific RNA. We further show that protein-RNA clusters convert into amyloid fibrils over a longer time-scale compared to condensates, therefore providing higher kinetic stability. The competition between clustering and phase separation reported in this study could provide a unifying framework to understand the distinct assemblies of hnRNPA1 in the nucleus and the cytoplasm, where the protein is exposed to different types and concentrations of RNA.