PRO-ADD: Patient-empowered dose-finding trials integrating safety, preliminary efficacy and patient-reported outcomes
Emily Alger1, Sumithra J Mandrekar2, Jun Yin3
1Clinical Trial and Statistics Unit, Institute of Cancer Research, UK.
Abstract:
Advances in oncology drug development are driving the emergence of novel therapies, challenging traditional dose-efficacy assumptions in dose-finding oncology trials. Traditional trial designs aim to identify a maximum tolerated dose (MTD) by assessing patients' dose-limiting toxicities (DLTs) - adopting traditional dose-efficacy paradigms that efficacy increases with treatment dose. With these new therapies in mind, emphasis should shift toward methodological advancements in trial designs aimed at identifying optimal doses, rather than solely determining MTDs. Incorporating patient-reported outcomes (PROs) within dose-finding oncology trials is increasingly recommended to better understand treatments' tolerability profiles, especially given the extended tolerability assessment windows for novel immunotherapies and targeted therapies. This article introduces PRO-ADD (Patient-Reported Outcomes Aided Dose-optimisation Design), a modular trial design framework for dose-optimisation. We leverage this framework to optimise dosage with respect to three key outcomes - clinician-assessed DLTs, PROs and preliminary efficacy. PRO-ADD performs well at identifying the optimal dose (both efficacious and tolerable) - successfully identifying the most tolerable effective dose and avoiding escalation to larger, safe doses offering no additional efficacy benefit. As the field evolves, patient-centric dose-finding approaches incorporating PROs are crucial in advancing our understanding of treatment tolerability, and in turn, shaping the future landscape of dose-finding oncology trials.
Insights
Novel oncology drugs require new trial designs. Patient-Reported Outcomes Aided Dose-optimisation Design (PRO-ADD) identifies optimal doses by balancing efficacy and tolerability, improving patient-centric cancer drug development.
Area of Science:
- Oncology
- Clinical Trial Design
- Pharmacometrics
Background:
- Novel cancer therapies challenge traditional dose-finding assumptions in oncology trials.
- Existing methods focus on Maximum Tolerated Dose (MTD), which may not be optimal for new treatments.
- Patient-Reported Outcomes (PROs) are crucial for assessing tolerability with novel immunotherapies and targeted therapies.
Purpose of the Study:
- To introduce PRO-ADD (Patient-Reported Outcomes Aided Dose-optimisation Design), a novel framework for dose-optimisation in oncology trials.
- To shift the focus from MTD identification to finding optimal, patient-centric doses.
- To integrate clinician-assessed dose-limiting toxicities (DLTs), PROs, and preliminary efficacy into dose-finding.
Main Methods:
- Development of the modular PRO-ADD framework for dose-optimisation.
- Leveraging PRO-ADD to optimise dosage based on DLTs, PROs, and efficacy.
- Evaluating PRO-ADD's performance in identifying the optimal dose.
Main Results:
- PRO-ADD successfully identifies the optimal dose, balancing efficacy and tolerability.
- The framework avoids escalating doses that offer no additional efficacy benefit.
- PRO-ADD demonstrates effectiveness in finding the most tolerable effective dose.
Conclusions:
- Patient-centric dose-finding approaches incorporating PROs are essential for advancing oncology.
- PRO-ADD provides a robust framework for optimising dosage in modern oncology trials.
- This methodology will shape the future of dose-finding studies for novel cancer therapies.
Related Concept Videos
Dosage Regimens: Designs and Approaches
Dosage Regimens: Partial Pharmacokinetic Parameters
Dosage Regimen: Individualization
Clinical Trials: Overview
Bioavailability Study Design: Healthy Subjects Versus Patients
Impact of Pharmacokinetic–Pharmacodynamic Models: Regulatory Decisions


