Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 5, 2026
Use of Electromagnetic Navigational Transthoracic Needle Aspiration E-TTNA for Sampling of Lung Nodules
Published on: May 23, 2015
Evolution of Diagnostic Yield for Peripheral Lung Nodule Biopsies With Changes in Navigational Bronchoscopy
Jason Beattie1, Raymond Parrish, Paula Aranguren
1Division of Thoracic Surgery and Interventional Pulmonology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.
Background:
Recent growth of navigational bronchoscopy has included use of new platforms and tools, the benefit of which remains under study.
Research Question:
Does diagnostic yield differ between: (a) electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy versus shape-sensing robotic-assisted bronchoscopy; (b) ssRAB versus ssRAB with cone-beam CT (ssRAB-CBCT); and (c) nodule sampling with versus without cryobiopsy?
Methods:
This single-center retrospective study evaluated the diagnostic performance of navigational bronchoscopy cases with acquisition of new platforms and tools at a bronchoscopy referral center between 2016 and March 2024. Diagnostic yield was evaluated for the primary procedural target, with yield defined as per ATS/ACCP guidelines.
Results:
A total of 185 ENB cases, 371 ssRAB cases, and 54 ssRAB-CBCT cases were available for comparison. Diagnostic yield was 57% for ENB, 72% for ssRAB and 78% for ssRAB-CBCT (ENB vs. ssRAB P=0.001; ssRAB vs. ssRAB-CBCT P=0.307). Diagnostic yield was 78% for ssRAB/ssRAB-CBCT procedures that used cryobiopsy versus 69% for procedures that did not (P=0.035). Nodule size differed between procedure types: median size 27 mm (IQR 17 to 35 mm) for ENB, 21 mm (IQR 16 to 30 mm) for ssRAB (P=0.001 for ENB vs. ssRAB), and 17 mm (IQR 13 to 25) for ssRAB-CBCT (P=0.004 for ssRAB vs. ssRAB-CBCT). Differences were found between ENB and ssRAB procedures regarding nodule location in the peripheral third of lung (ENB 50% vs. ssRAB 62%, P=0.009) and presence of a bronchus sign (ENB 81% vs. ssRAB 43%, P=<0.001), whereas other nodule characteristics were similar between groups.
Conclusion:
Acquisition of new tools for navigational bronchoscopy was associated with increased diagnostic yield despite performing biopsies on increasingly difficult cases.
