Protein Response to ACL Injury in Humans Show Early Cartilage Remodeling and Differences by Sex

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears increase the risk for developing posttraumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA). Females have greater risk for both. However, studies defining sex-specific protein responses in human cartilage after ACL injury are lacking. We hypothesize that articular cartilage's response to an injurious environment differs depending on sex.

We compared the proteomic profiles of normal cartilage with injured cartilage harvested from the intercondylar area during ACL surgery. Sex-specific injury effects were estimated through contrasts between Injured Male and Normal Male and between Injured Female and Normal Female. Pathway enrichment analysis was done using gene ontology (GO) and compared against the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) database. Extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins were further analyzed using the Matrisome AnalyzeR.

From the 2,188 proteins identified, males and females shared 1,121 upregulated and 23 downregulated proteins in injured compared to normal cartilage. Analysis of ECM proteins and enriched pathways revealed mostly similar male and female responses to an injurious environment, with evidence of early cartilage remodeling in both sexes. Nevertheless, more than 240 proteins were affected specifically by sex, and significant sex differences were found in inflammation, ECM-related, and metabolic pathways. Males were enriched mostly in "ECM-receptor interaction", while females were enriched in "Citrate cycle (TCA cycle)", "Fatty acid degradation", and "Fatty acid metabolism" pathways.

Articular cartilage shows signs of remodeling soon after ACL injury, even when only exposed to an injurious environment rather than being physically impacted. Sex differences were observed in inflammation, metabolic pathways, and ECM synthesis.