Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jun 17, 2026

Evaluation of an Exclusive Spur Dike U-Turn Design with Radar-Collected Data and Simulation
Published on: February 1, 2020
Evaluation of Arizona's statewide handheld cellphone ban using roadside observation and telematics data
Ian J Reagan1, Jessica B Cicchino1
1Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 4121 Wilson Blvd., 6(th) floor, Arlington, VA 22203, USA.
Introduction:
This study assessed whether a ban against drivers holding phones reduces such behavior. In 2019, Arizona passed a statewide prohibition on holding a cellphone. Police could issue written warnings immediately but could only issue citations beginning in 2021.
Method:
We used a pre-post study with control group design to estimate handheld phone use in Arizona before and after citations were permitted relative to Nevada. The before-citations period was limited to April 2019 through December 2020. Roadside observations occurred in July 2019 and 2021. Telematics data onhandheld phone usewas analyzed using the same before period and two different post periods, one short- and one long-term (2021 and 2021-2024).
Results:
Analyses showed consistently lower likelihood of handheld calling in Arizona after citations were permitted, though only the telematics analyses were statistically significant. For example, the telematics data showed that the percentage of trip time with handheld calls decreased 26% by 2024. Roadside observation indicated phone manipulation decreased in Arizona after January 2021 but not significantly. Short-term telematics analysis found small changes in phone manipulation: the percentage of trip time with manipulation decreased, but the percentage of trips with any manipulation increased. The long-term analysis showed that both measures increased by 2024. Citations written by state troopers declined each year from 2021 to 2024.
Conclusion:
Handheld calling reductions in Arizona estimated after the law's effective date were robust and consistent with earlier work. The lack of robust decline in manipulation may reflect preexisting local ordinances prohibiting phone use in some Arizona jurisdictions or the limited before-citations period. The increase in cellphone manipulation over time is consistent with the decline in enforcement.
Practical Applications:
Long-term increases in manipulation suggest that the temptation to use smartphones is stronger than concerns about receiving a citation, and therefore additional interventions will be required.
Related Concept Videos
Schemas
Archival Research
Naturalistic Observations
Design Example: Identifying the Locations of Monuments in the Field Using Global Positioning System Device
Holter Monitor: 24-Hour Monitoring

