A frame-based approach for reconstructing theories

Area of Science:

• Philosophy of Science
• Theoretical Frameworks
• Scientific Theory Analysis

Background:

• Existing frame models require expansion for comprehensive scientific theory analysis.
• Need for a structured approach to define theoretical concepts and their relations.

Purpose of the Study:

• To expand the frame model using theory frame modules (TFMs) for scientific theory analysis.
• To propose frame-based definitions for theoretical concepts and intertheoretical relations.
• To distinguish between operationalist and unificationist approaches to scientific concepts.

Main Methods:

• Development and application of theory frame modules (TFMs) to analyze three scientific theories.
• Frame-based definition of theoretical concepts.
• Frame-based definition of intertheoretical relations (specialization, theoretization).
• Distinction between narrow and broad senses of recursion within frames.
• Frame-based distinction between operationalist and unificationist approaches.

Main Results:

• Illustration of TFMs applied to theories with varying measurement scales.
• Establishment of frame-based definitions for theoretical concepts and intertheoretical relations.
• Differentiated perspective on recursion within frames.
• Proposed distinction between operationalist and unificationist approaches to scientific concepts.

Conclusions:

• Theory frame modules offer a robust framework for analyzing scientific theories.
• Frame-based definitions enhance the understanding of theoretical concepts and their interrelations.
• The proposed approach provides a novel way to distinguish between different philosophical stances on scientific concepts.