Collaborative care intervention for risky opioid use among primary care patients: The STOP randomized clinical trial

Individuals who engage in illicit or nonmedical opioid use may have elevated risk of health and social consequences, including progression to opioid use disorder (OUD). Preventive interventions to reduce this risk are lacking. This trial tested the impact of a primary care-integrated collaborative care approach for reducing risky opioid use, defined as nonmedical use of prescription opioids or any use of illicit opioids.

Cluster-randomized controlled trial randomized primary care providers (PCPs) and their patients into the Subthreshold Opioid Use Disorder Prevention (STOP) intervention or enhanced usual care (EUC).

Primary care clinics at 5 U.S. sites.

PCPs and their patients were recruited January 2021-May 2023. A total of 119 PCP clusters (STOP = 48, EUC = 51) and 202 patients (STOP = 88, EUC = 114) enrolled. Eligible patients were adults (≥18 years) having current risky opioid use, without moderate-severe OUD. Patient participants were majority female (63.4%), white (70.8%) and non-Hispanic (96.5%), with a mean age of 55.7 [standard deviation (SD) = 12.7] years. At baseline, 63.4% of participants had moderate-severe pain (Brief Pain Inventory) and below average physical (79.2%) and mental (62.4%) health (SF-12).

The STOP collaborative care intervention consisted of brief advice from the PCP about reducing risky opioid use, meetings with a clinic-embedded nurse care manager over 12 months and remote health coaching (2-6 sessions). Both groups received primary care treatment as usual and overdose risk reduction materials.

The primary outcome was total days of risky opioid use, recorded from 6 monthly electronic surveys. A key secondary outcome was moderate-severe OUD at 6 and 12 months.

A total of 77 (87.5%) STOP and 107 (93.9%) EUC participants completed the 6-month assessment period. The primary outcome analysis used the Intention-to-Treat sample with multiple imputations of missing data. Mean days of risky opioid use at 180 days were lower in STOP than EUC [12.2 (SD = 27.73) vs. 15.5 (SD = 32.64)]; the difference between groups adjusted for baseline risky opioid use was not statistically significant (rate ratio 0.95, 95% confidence interval = 0.52-1.74). One STOP participant (1.1%) and 13 EUC participants (11.4%) developed moderate-severe OUD at 6 months, and 3 (3.4%) STOP and 6 (5.3%) EUC participants had moderate-severe OUD at 12 months (P < 0.001).

This cluster-randomized controlled trial did not find evidence that the STOP intervention for reducing risky opioid use produced greater reductions over 6 months compared with enhanced usual care, though fewer intervention participants progressed to moderate-severe opioid use disorder. Patients had a high burden of pain and comorbidities that may present challenges to reducing opioid use.