Scanning tunneling microscopy of ferrocenecarboxylic acid assemblies on Ag(111): a comparison to Au(111)

Scanning tunneling microscopy was used to investigate the arrangement of ferrocenecarboxylic acid (FcCOOH) monolayers on the Ag(111) surface. Four distinct structures were observed, none of which had previously been observed on other surfaces. Structural analysis indicates that these assemblies are primarily composed of dimers. VASP calculations support the molecular assignments of the monolayer structures, while ESI-MS experiments confirm that dimers are the predominant species in solution. Of particular note, the cyclic pentamers and aperiodic packing observed for FcCOOH on Au(111) were not observed, despite (1) the similarity of the Ag(111) and Au(111) surfaces in reactivity, flatness, and lattice constant, and (2) prior explanation of the Au(111) monolayer in terms of molecule-molecule interactions alone. It is clear that while the surface does not have a template structure, it has a significant influence on which structures are formed.