Traffic-Weighted Detour Ratio Identifies Inefficient Cycling Routes

Urban congestion is simultaneously influenced by heterogeneous spatio-temporal travel demands, the topology and spatial characteristics of road networks, and the interplay between multiple travel modes. As a critical component of solutions towards a greener and more sustainable transportation, bike-sharing systems have great potential in reducing carbon emissions, improving public health, and alleviating congestion by substituting short-distance motorized trips. Benefiting from flexible accessibility and usage, dockless bike-sharing has gained wide popularity and revived the fashion of cycling in cities. In this study, we reveal that the widely adopted detour ratio alone cannot effectively reflect congestion levels at the route level. Using large-scale dockless bike-sharing data and taxi trajectory data in Beijing, we quantitatively examine the relationships between cycling flow, motor vehicle traffic and road network structure. In addition, the proposed cycling-traffic-weighted detour ratio can prescreen potentially inefficient cycling routes, which can assist targeted infrastructure optimization and evidence-based urban planning.