Persistent cloaca without vaginal-common channel fistula: A Case series characterizing a rare phenotype

Persistent cloaca occurs in approximately 1 in 25,000 live births. Among patients with cloaca, the absence of a vaginal connection to the common channel represents a rare phenotype with distinct anatomic and management considerations. We describe the urologic, gynecologic, and surgical characteristics of this patient subset.

We performed a retrospective analysis of a single-institution cohort of patients with persistent cloaca managed at a quaternary-care children's hospital between 2019 and 2025. Patients were eligible if they underwent primary cloacal repair by our multidisciplinary team and met all three diagnostic criteria for absent vaginal-common channel fistula: no hydrocolpos on imaging, no identified vaginal opening on cystoscopy or cloacagram, and no visible lumen between müllerian and cloacal structures identified intraoperatively.

Of 51 patients who underwent primary repair, 6 (12%) met criteria for absent vaginal-common channel fistula. All met criteria for VACTEGRLS association. Common channel length ranged from 1.1 to 7.0 cm and urethral length from 0.5 to 2.2 cm. Urologic anomalies were nearly universal: five patients (83%) had a solitary functional kidney and four (67%) had vesicoureteral reflux. All underwent posterior sagittal anorectoplasty (PSARP) for rectal repair with the common channel repurposed as the neourethra. Five (83%) underwent diagnostic laparoscopy during which the müllerian structures were examined but left in situ. At last follow-up (median 17.5 months, range 4-35 months), three patients (50%) had volitional voiding and three (50%) required assisted bladder emptying via vesicostomy or Mitrofanoff.

Persistent cloaca without a vaginal-common channel fistula represents a rare but clinically distinct phenotype characterized by severe urologic anomalies. Recognition of this phenotype is essential for surgical planning and long-term urologic and gynecologic surveillance. Because there was no connection between the vagina and the urinary tract, delaying management of the müllerian structures did not adversely affect the urinary tract.