Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 12, 2026

A Microcontroller Operated Device for the Generation of Liquid Extracts from Conventional Cigarette Smoke and Electronic Cigarette Aerosol
Published on: January 18, 2018
Addressing challenges in reviewing e-cigarette evidence: proposing a new 'Test for Dominance' in systematic reviews
Garth Reid1,2, Glenna Nightingale3, Nason Maani3
1Public Health Scotland, 1 South Gyle Crescent, Edinburgh EH12 9EB, UK.
Background:
Current systematic review evidence on e-cigarettes as a smoking cessation tool is contested. Part of the reason for this is the difficulty of objectively assessing the limited and heterogeneous evidence base.The study aim was to develop a novel approach to testing the validity of systematic reviews and assessing the extent of the dominance of included primary studies.
Methods:
Leave-one-out meta-analysis was used to measure dominance. The systematic review on e-cigarettes as a smoking cessation tool by Hanewinkel et al. was used as a proof of concept.
Results:
The Hajek et al. study dominates the Hanewinkel et al. systematic review, exerting a disproportionate influence on the overall pooled effect.
Conclusions:
This research has identified a gap in current approaches to validity testing in systematic reviews. The Test for Dominance could supplement existing testing, including tests for heterogeneity, sensitivity analysis, and subgroup analysis. When a single study dominates a systematic review, the findings of that review should be interpreted with caution and further randomised controlled trials undertaken to reduce such distortion.
More Related Videos
09:50Impact Assessment of Repeated Exposure of Organotypic 3D Bronchial and Nasal Tissue Culture Models to Whole Cigarette Smoke
Published on: February 12, 2015
08:39Generation of Electronic Cigarette Aerosol by a Third-Generation Machine-Vaping Device: Application to Toxicological Studies
Published on: August 25, 2018
Related Concept Videos
Criteria for Causality: Bradford Hill Criteria - II
Strategies for Assessing and Addressing Confounding
Confounding can be addressed at both the design phase of a study and through analytical methods after data...
Confounding in Epidemiological Studies
Bias in Epidemiological Studies
Cochran's Q Test