Artificial autonomy and algorithmic paternalism: AI shaping human autonomy and decision-making

While artificial intelligence (AI) systems can enhance human autonomy, they also challenge human self-determination as they exhibit "artificial autonomy" and enact "algorithmic paternalism". This article examines how AI can influence three core preconditions of autonomy - understanding, decision-making competence, and voluntariness. Moreover, it analyses breaches of three standard conceptions of autonomy (as agency, as authenticity, and as relational autonomy). The article further describes how the agentic appearance and perceived authority of AI systems can undermine human autonomy and enact "algorithmic paternalism" corresponding to traditional forms of paternalism. The complexity and opacity of AI systems challenge human autonomy in special and unprecedented ways which may have vast implications for individuals and societies. Therefore, identifying artificial autonomy and algorithmic paternalism and their mechanisms is crucial for preserving human autonomy.