Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 6, 2026

A Novel Method for Involving Women of Color at High Risk for Preterm Birth in Research Priority Setting
Published on: January 12, 2018
Evolving Identities or Racial Misclassification? Fluidity in race response among American Indian birthing people in
Danielle R Gartner1, Bendu Sherman1, Ross Rogers1,2
1Department of Epidemiology & Biostatistics, College of Human Medicine, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI.
We sought to characterize racial identity response transitions among multiparous birthing people who ever identified as American Indian or Alaska Native (AIAN) and assess whether this fluidity alters year-specific statewide AIAN maternal health and birth outcome prevalence estimates. To do so, we used Michigan birth certificates (2014-2022) to identify individuals with $\boldsymbol{\ge}$2 live births who self-reported as AIAN for $\boldsymbol{\ge}\mathbf{1}$ birth (n = 4823). We categorized individuals as having changed or not changed their reported racial identity across births and recalculated AIAN-specific outcome estimates accordingly. Only 23.9% (1155) consistently identified as AIAN across all births, while 76.1% (3668) used different racial identity responses. Among those whose racial identity response changed, transitioning from identifying as AIAN to no longer identifying as AIAN was the most common pattern. Accounting for these transitions had minimal effect on prevalence estimates for preterm birth and gestational diabetes, while there were some prevalence changes for the prevalence of smoking before/during pregnancy. AIAN birthing people in Michigan often shift racial identity responses over time. Although this fluidity had little impact on surveillance of perinatal outcomes, reliance on point-in-time race data may inadequately reflect AIAN identity in public health data.
We sought to characterize racial identity response transitions among multiparous birthing people who ever identified as American Indian or Alaska Native (AIAN) and assess whether this fluidity alters year-specific statewide AIAN maternal health and birth outcome prevalence estimates. To do so, we used Michigan birth certificates (2014-2022) to identify individuals with $\boldsymbol{\ge}$2 live births who self-reported as AIAN for $\boldsymbol{\ge}\mathbf{1}$ birth (n = 4823). We categorized individuals as having changed or not changed their reported racial identity across births and recalculated AIAN-specific outcome estimates accordingly. Only 23.9% (1155) consistently identified as AIAN across all births, while 76.1% (3668) used different racial identity responses. Among those whose racial identity response changed, transitioning from identifying as AIAN to no longer identifying as AIAN was the most common pattern. Accounting for these transitions had minimal effect on prevalence estimates for preterm birth and gestational diabetes, while there were some prevalence changes for the prevalence of smoking before/during pregnancy. AIAN birthing people in Michigan often shift racial identity responses over time. Although this fluidity had little impact on surveillance of perinatal outcomes, reliance on point-in-time race data may inadequately reflect AIAN identity in public health data.
Related Concept Videos
Ethnic Identity within a Larger Culture
Stereotypes, Prejudice, and Discrimination
Surveys
Regression Toward the Mean
Genetic Drift
Steps in Outbreak Investigation
