Effect of Diagnostic Test Type on Detection of Salmonella Infections - Foodborne Diseases Active Surveillance...

Salmonella species bacterial infections are a leading cause of enteric illness and can be diagnosed using bacterial culture or culture-independent diagnostic tests (CIDTs). All culture-diagnosed cases are considered culture confirmed. After a positive CIDT, infection can be culture confirmed if reflex culture is attempted and yields an isolate. A culture-unconfirmed infection is a CIDT-diagnosed infection for which reflex culture was not attempted or failed to yield an isolate. Foodborne Diseases Active Surveillance Network data from 2006 through 2023 were analyzed to compare the epidemiologic and clinical characteristics of Salmonella infections after stratifying by diagnostic method (culture versus CIDT) and culture confirmation status (culture confirmed versus unconfirmed). To improve the precision and stability of temporal trend estimates, incidence trends during 2004-2024, as opposed to 2006-2023, were evaluated overall, by diagnostic method, and by confirmation status using regression. Although overall incidence remained stable from 2004 through 2024, the incidence of culture-diagnosed and -confirmed infections declined, and the incidence of CIDT-diagnosed and unconfirmed infections increased. Culture- and CIDT-diagnosed Salmonella infections were demographically similar but exhibited distinct clinical patterns, with CIDT diagnosis associated with milder and more sporadic illnesses, which suggests that these infections were historically underdiagnosed by culture-based diagnostics. The success of prevention efforts that reduce more severe, traditionally culture-detected Salmonella infections might be offset by the expanded detection of milder infections through CIDTs. The increases in detection of milder infections through CIDTs may offset the results of successes in prevention efforts in reduction in severe Salmonella infections. Understanding how diagnostic methods influence observed surveillance trends is therefore critical for evaluating and guiding future prevention efforts.