Mechanistic diversity of clamp loading at small DNA gaps

DNA sliding clamps, including PCNA (proliferating cell nuclear antigen) and the 9-1-1 (RAD9-RAD1-HUS1 in humans) complex, are ring-shaped protein complexes that encircle DNA and serve as central interaction platforms in DNA replication, repair, and checkpoint signaling. While clamp loading at canonical primer-template junctions by AAA+ (ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities) clamp loaders is well established, how clamps are loaded onto physiologically relevant but geometrically constrained DNA intermediates, such as nicks and single-stranded gaps, has remained unclear. Recent cryo-electron microscopy studies reveal that clamp loaders have evolved distinct strategies to overcome these constraints and to specialize for different genomic contexts. At gapped DNA, the eukaryotic clamp loader RFC (replication factor C) engages both 3'- and 5'-recessed DNA ends and can locally unwind DNA, enabling PCNA loading across a wide range of gap sizes. In contrast, the bacterial DnaX clamp loader lacks a 5'-DNA binding site and does not unwind DNA, instead loading the β-clamp at small gaps (<6 nt) by sharply bending DNA. The checkpoint clamp loader Rad24-RFC (RAD17-RFC in humans) similarly lacks DNA unwinding activity, restricting loading of 9-1-1 clamp to larger gaps (≥6 nt). In a distinct specialization, Ctf18-RFC interacts with the leading-strand DNA polymerase ε, positioning it as a dedicated loader for leading-strand synthesis, whereas Elg1-RFC (ATAD5-RFC in humans) excludes DNA from its chamber and functions as a PCNA unloader. Together, these mechanisms illustrate how clamp loaders are diversified to accommodate DNA structure and replisome context, ensuring coordinated control of genome replication and maintenance.