Improved spike-in normalization clarifies the relationship between active histone modifications and transcription

Spike-in normalization enables quantitative analysis of chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing (ChIP-seq) signal. Here we introduce a robust dual spike-in normalization approach for ChIP-seq (ChIP-wrangler), optimize parameters and verify its accuracy in quantifying changes in ChIP-seq signal and detecting technical artifacts. We use ChIP-wrangler to revisit recent claims that active histone marks depend on transcription. We show that acute depletion of RNA polymerase II (RNAPII) has a modest impact on H3K27ac levels, with only 6% of peaks significantly changing after RNAPII depletion, indicating that histone acetylation maintenance is not entirely dependent on ongoing transcription. Promoters and enhancers are differentially affected, with 82% of decreasing acetylation peaks located at promoter-distal elements with enhancer-related motifs. ChIP-wrangler provides increased rigor and 'guardrails' for successful spike-in normalization and, as applied here, refines the understanding of crosstalk between RNAPII activity and transcription-associated histone marks.