Related Experiment Videos
Everything Is Prediction: Modern Machine Learning as Bayesian Inference
Nicholas G Polson1, Vadim Sokolov2, Refik Soyer3
1Booth School of Business, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA.
Abstract:
We argue that the core methods of modern machine learning-conformal prediction, large language models and in-context learning, and generative/diffusion models-are not rivals to Bayesian inference but implementations of it, almost always of its predictive (de Finetti) form rather than its parameter-centric (prior-to-posterior) form. (1) Background: A quarter-century after Breiman contrasted the "data-modeling" and "algorithmic" cultures of statistics, we revisit that dichotomy and argue that the predictive view dissolves it-both cultures target the one-step-ahead density p(yn+1∣y1:n), differing only in how they compute it. (2) Methods: We organize the modern toolkit around this predictive object and around amortization-replacing per-dataset inference with a single map learned by simulation-using Generative Bayesian Computation (GBC) as the connective spine. (3) Results: Conformal prediction, autoregressive language models, prior-data fitted networks, and score-based diffusion are each shown to construct, calibrate, or sample from the predictive object, summarized in a single "Rosetta" table; because all are fit by proper scoring rules-equivalently, by Bregman divergences-the information-theoretic frame is the natural unifier. (4) Conclusions: The equivalence is exact in idealized limits, asymptotic under exchangeability and its martingale relaxations, and measurably approximate for trained models-a three-grade taxonomy that we make explicit, row by row, and that bounds the thesis: prediction is not attribution, and the predictive view is deliberately silent about causal structures.
Related Concept Videos
Predicting Products: SN1 vs. SN2
With increased substitution on the alkyl halide,...
Predicting Reaction Outcomes
Mechanistic Models: Compartment Models in Individual and Population Analysis