Paralogous evolution of the ITS2 region in Xiphophorus

Ribosomal ITS2 is widely used in phylogenetic studies, yet its multigene organization and potential paralogy can obscure true species relationships. This proof-of-concept study investigates whether ITS2 sequences derived from long-read genomic data in multiple Xiphophorus species primarily reflect orthologous history or are shaped by ancient and local duplications. Phylogenetic analyses reveal two major, reciprocally mirroring ITS2 clades that represent long-standing paralogous rDNA lineages rather than simple allelic variants. The two paralogons show strong asymmetry in copy retention and loss for the majority of the species analyzed in this study. Exceptionally some other species are confined to one paralogon group and exhibit alternating ITS2 variants consistent with persistent ancestral polymorphism. A striking copy number imbalance in X. variatus, combined with its phylogenetic incongruence relative to the established species tree, is best explained by historical rDNA introgression followed by biased concerted evolution that nearly erased one paralogous copy. Despite incomplete homogenization, heterogeneous evolutionary rates, and occasional long-branch artifacts, the recovered paralog-specific topologies largely recapitulate the accepted Xiphophorus species phylogeny, indicating that ITS2 retains a robust organismal signal while also recording episodes of introgression and differential paralog evolution. These results demonstrate that explicit recognition of ITS2 paralogs can both improve phylogenetic interpretation and open avenues for future sequence-structure-based analyses of rDNA evolution and genus-level systematics in Xiphophorus.