Prion disease mimicking rapidly progressive Alzheimer disease: case series and systematic review

Prion disease and Alzheimer disease (AD) are common causes of rapidly progressive dementia (RPD). Although most patients with prion disease are distinguished by MRI and CSF findings, selected cases mimic rapidly progressive AD. We characterized AD-prion disease mimics within a prospective cohort and the extant literature to identify the clinical features and tests that support accurate diagnoses in these patients.

Patients with prion disease initially diagnosed as rapidly progressive AD were identified from a prospective cohort study at Mayo Clinic (February 2020-June 2026) and through systematic review of MEDLINE and Embase.

Of 204 patients with RPD, five (2.5%) were initially diagnosed with clinically probable AD but ultimately determined to have prion disease. Systematic review identified 10 additional cases (n=15, median age-at-onset, 59 years; 67% male). Presentations reproduced amnestic (53%), dysexecutive (27%), primary progressive aphasia (13%), and posterior cortical atrophy (7%) AD phenotypes; median time from AD diagnosis to consideration of prion disease was 2 months. Diffusion-weighted MRI abnormalities were absent in Mayo Clinic cases and absent/equivocal (n=2) or overlooked (n=8) in published cases. CSF biomarkers were consistent with AD in 6/9 tested patients, with elevated total tau levels in 11/13 patients and total-tau/p hosphorylated-tau181 ratios in 5/9 patients. Real-time quaking-induced conversion assays for prions were positive in the CSF of 9/12 patients. Prion disease was confirmed by neuropathology (n=7), genetics (n=2), or real-time quaking-induced conversion (n=6) assays.

Prion disease may rarely mimic rapidly progressive AD. Disproportionate elevations in CSF total-tau levels or total-tau/p hosphorylated-tau181 ratios should prompt consideration of prion disease.