Comprehensive functional testing in fibroblasts has strong utility to diagnose mitochondrial disease

Genome sequencing is the first-line diagnostic method for primary mitochondrial diseases (PMDs), yet its effectiveness is limited by variants of uncertain significance or unresolved genetic findings. We systematically evaluated the clinical performance of fibroblast-based functional testing, comprised of respiratory chain enzyme assays, blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis with in-gel activity staining (BN-PAGE), complex I assembly assay, and targeted protein abundance assessments, in a cohort of 204 genetically confirmed PMD patients, 51 healthy controls, and 53 patients with differential diagnoses. Individually, enzyme assays, BN-PAGE, and complex I assembly assay showed sensitivities of 46%, 40%, and 49%, with specificities of 93%, 98%, and 99%, respectively. Combined, the assays achieved an overall sensitivity of 76%, a specificity 93%, a positive predictive value 96%, and a negative predictive value of 67%. Sensitivity was highest for isolated respiratory chain deficiencies, nuclear DNA-encoded mitochondrial translation defects, cofactor deficiencies, and mitochondrial aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase disorders, whereas mitochondrial DNA variants and maintenance defects remained challenging. Secondary mitochondrial dysfunction was rare. The strong clinical utility of comprehensive fibroblast functional testing improves PMD diagnosis when used complementary to genomic sequencing.