Life in sediments fosters 'sexual' speciation in the Shewanella baltica complex

Understanding how intra- and interspecific differentiation arises in natural microbial populations is central to explaining the processes that drive bacterial evolution. Motivated by the co-occurrence of multiple putative genospecies closely related to Shewanella baltica in Baltic Sea sediments, we investigated the genomic structure of this species complex across fine spatial scales. We analyzed 112 genome sequences from strains collected across several sediment cores and depths (0-6 cm) at Vaxön (Stockholm archipelago, Sweden) as well as earlier isolates from this site and allopatric strains from surrounding locations obtained from both sediments and the water column. Using a reverse-ecology population genomics approach, we found unprecedented genomic diversification among sediment-associated strains, which form a species complex resolving into three cohesive evolutionary groups (G1, G2, and G3) with distinct signatures of metabolic specialization including sulfite respiration. While G1 consists predominantly of a single species (S. baltica) with high gene turnover, G2 and G3 comprise an array of divergent putative genospecies and previously reported species consistently recovered from sediments. Patterns of homologous recombination indicate that diversification of the lineages within G2 and G3 is primarily recombination-driven ('sexual') and is associated with specialization in sulfite reduction and utilization of certain carbon sources. The extent of diversity uncovered here far exceeds that reported for S. baltica from other environments, suggesting that a sediment-associated lifestyle promotes the emergence of novel genotypes. These findings expand the known limits of sympatric speciation in prokaryotes beyond subspecific ecotypes, demonstrating that bacterial species can diverge and persist as distinct lineages in the absence of spatial segregation and at microgeographic scales. Furthermore, our results suggest that collective interactions and ecological differentiation can structure sediment-associated bacterial populations strongly enough to drive divergence at the species level.