Towards an integrative neuroscience of metacognition

Metacognition enables organisms to self-evaluate their own cognitive processes. In humans, this capacity underpins adaptive learning, social coordination and the formation of self-beliefs about skill and ability. A core motif that underpins multiple forms of metacognition is the ability to form estimates of performance in a self-directed frame of reference, expressed as propositional confidence about one's own behaviour and mental processes. Convergent behavioural, computational and neural evidence obtained across rodents, non-human primates and humans indicates that these self-evaluations arise from structured transformations of uncertainty. Dynamic evidence accumulation processes provide candidate building blocks for local confidence, whereas multimodal prefrontal brain areas integrate these signals to support abstract, global self-beliefs. This architecture supports metacognitive control at multiple timescales, from rapid error correction to strategic task arbitration and social communication. Dysfunctional metacognition can lead to disorders of reality monitoring and insight, in which erroneous mental representations are endorsed with aberrant confidence. By integrating computational, cross-species and clinical perspectives, metacognitive neuroscience offers a bridge from neural circuit mechanisms to subjective experience.