Pilot study of allele-specific multi-InDel markers for the detection of extremely unbalanced DNA mixtures

Mixtures are common in forensic casework, and they represent one of the most challenging types of biological evidence. Traditional short tandem repeat analyses are often associated with limitations when dealing with extremely unbalanced mixtures because alleles from minor contributors can easily be masked by those of major contributors. Consequently, researchers have developed new technologies and methods for improving the analysis of mixtures, spanning upstream DNA extraction and downstream software analysis. Among these, strategies combining allele-specific amplification with compound markers have drawn particular interest because of their ability to selectively detect minor contributors in complex mixtures. In this study, we screened multi-InDels across the entire genome, designed allele-specific primers compatible with the capillary electrophoresis platform, and further explored their potential in unbalanced DNA mixtures and cell-free fetal DNA (cffDNA). Ultimately, a set comprising 10 multi-InDels was developed, and this included two groups of primers that separately amplified the long alleles (L primer set) and short alleles (S primer set). The results demonstrated that each primer pair could detect the minor component at a 1:1000 mixture ratio, whereas the L and S primer sets successfully detected the minor contributors at mixture ratios of 1:200 and 1:500, respectively. Furthermore, in the cffDNA analysis, 60 of 78 informative markers were successfully detected, with the complete detection of all informative markers achieved in 18 mother-child reference pairs. Overall, allele-specific amplification-based multi-InDel markers enabled the sensitive detection of minor contributors, providing a potential strategy for the analysis of unbalanced two-person mixtures.